Coronial
QLDhospital

Saunders, Ryan Charles

Deceased

Ryan Charles Saunders

Demographics

2y, male

Coroner

Barnes

Date of death

2007-09-26

Finding date

2011-10-07

Cause of death

Group A Streptococcal toxic shock syndrome which probably originated in the throat

AI-generated summary

Ryan Saunders, a 2-year-old boy, died from Group A Streptococcal toxic shock syndrome after a 72-hour presentation with fever, pain, and systemic illness. Initial GP care was appropriate given the presentation and diagnostic uncertainty. At Rockhampton Base Hospital, critical diagnostic and management failures occurred: no septic work-up or blood cultures despite lumbar puncture for suspected meningitis; refusal of adequate analgesia (morphine) based on diagnostic concern when weaker analgesics were failing; and incomplete review of the child's previous analgesic therapy and high fever (38.7°C on arrival). Had blood cultures and CRP been obtained promptly on admission, bacterial infection would have been identified and antibiotics initiated, likely saving the child's life. The consultant prioritised diagnostic precision over symptom relief in a deteriorating child, overruling junior doctors who correctly suggested toxic workup and enhanced pain management.

AI-generated summary and tagging — may contain inaccuracies; refer to original finding for legal purposes. Report an inaccuracy.

Specialties

paediatricsemergency medicineinfectious diseasesgeneral practiceradiologysurgeryanaesthesia

Error types

diagnosticcommunicationdelaysystem

Drugs involved

paracetamolibuprofenmorphinefentanylcodeineceftriaxonegentamicinmetronidazoleampicillin

Clinical conditions

Group A Streptococcal infectiontoxic shock syndromesepsismeningismsuspected appendicitissuspected intussusceptionfeversevere paindehydrationelevated creatinine kinaseelevated C-reactive protein

Procedures

lumbar punctureabdominal ultrasoundabdominal x-raychest x-rayCT scan of abdomenportable chest x-raycannulation and contrast injectioncatheterisationnasogastric tube insertionintubation

Contributing factors

  • Failure to perform septic work-up or blood cultures after lumbar puncture on admission
  • Failure to obtain CRP level which would have identified bacterial infection
  • Delayed diagnosis of bacterial infection until approximately 3:30pm on day 2 (too late)
  • Inadequate pain management despite evidence of severe pain
  • Withholding of morphine based on diagnostic concern rather than clinical need
  • Incomplete assessment of child's prior analgesic therapy
  • Unaware of high initial temperature (38.7°C) on arrival and prior morphine administration
  • Failure to review patient after escalation of pain relief and receipt of abnormal blood results
  • Consultant reliance on junior doctors without adequate oversight of deteriorating child
  • Atypical presentation of Group A Streptococcal infection making clinical diagnosis difficult

Coroner's recommendations

  1. Orientation of retrieval staff to include training on service capability levels of all Queensland hospitals with immediate online access
  2. Review policies to ensure appropriate access to tertiary level telemedical advice for rural and regional medical officers
  3. Implement forced CRP reporting tool state-wide
  4. Review accessibility of educative tools and clinical guidelines on Clinical Knowledge Network
  5. Develop and implement formal on-call process to ensure radiological imaging available 24/7 at Rockhampton Hospital with state-wide expansion consideration
  6. Implement formal process to ensure handover between shifts at senior medical officer and consultant level at Rockhampton Hospital
  7. Consider developing and implementing early warning observation system for all Queensland paediatric facilities (Children's Early Warning Tool - CEWT)
  8. Implement escalation procedure for pathology reports with automated alert system for significant variances
  9. Review nursing practices and processes impacting nursing care at Rockhampton Hospital
  10. Undertake review of communication within healthcare team in Paediatrics Unit at Rockhampton Hospital
  11. Medical Board of Queensland to consider further investigations into management and supervision by Dr Peter Roper
  12. Implement recommendations from Root Cause Analysis including PLS training, rostering review, education on septic shock and toxic shock syndrome
  13. Queensland Emergency Medical System Coordination Centre to review and improve sentinel event review processes and staff training
  14. Forensic and Scientific Services to review mortuary practices and develop state-wide guidelines for recording, storage and retention of autopsy information
  15. Ensure forensic pathologists have system access to both forensic and clinical modules in pathology system
  16. Establish formalised quality improvement processes within Rockhampton Hospital Paediatric Unit including Mortality and Morbidity Committee
Full text

Source and disclaimer

This page reproduces or summarises information from publicly available findings published by Australian coroners' courts. Coronial is an independent educational resource and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of any coronial court or government body.

Content may be incomplete, reformatted, or summarised. Some material may have been redacted or restricted by court order or privacy requirements. Always refer to the original court publication for the authoritative record.

Copyright in original materials remains with the relevant government jurisdiction. AI-generated summaries and tagging are for educational purposes only, may contain inaccuracies, and must not be treated as legal documents. We welcome feedback for correction — report an inaccuracy here.