Coronial
NSWhospital

Inquest into the death of Manjit SINGH

Deceased

Manjit Singh

Demographics

33y, male

Coroner

Decision ofDeputy State Coroner Dillon

Date of death

2011-08-26

Finding date

2015-08-17

Cause of death

hypoxic respiratory failure following right pneumonectomy for treatment of severe pulmonary tuberculosis

AI-generated summary

Manjit Singh, a 33-year-old Indian 457 visa worker, died from hypoxic respiratory failure following a pneumonectomy for treatment of severe pulmonary tuberculosis. He had latent TB identified pre-arrival in India. Critical clinical lessons include: the importance of face-to-face pre-discharge TB screening with physical examination rather than telephone assessments; reviewing radiologist reports alongside clinician interpretation (discharge radiologist's report suggesting possible effusion was not reviewed before discharge); recognition that visa holders with uncertain immigration status may conceal symptoms; and the vulnerability of migrant workers to exploitation affecting nutrition and TB reactivation risk. His disease relapsed despite initial drug treatment, necessitating surgery. The coroner found malnutrition a contributory factor. Systemic improvements needed in coordination between immigration and health authorities for migrant health surveillance.

AI-generated summary and tagging — may contain inaccuracies; refer to original finding for legal purposes. Report an inaccuracy.

Specialties

respiratory medicinecardiothoracic surgeryintensive careinfectious diseasespublic health

Error types

diagnosticcommunicationsystem

Drugs involved

tuberculosis medications

Clinical conditions

pulmonary tuberculosis (active)latent tuberculosis (reactivation)malnutritionvitamin d deficiencyfolate deficiencyanaemiarespiratory failurehypoxic respiratory failurehospital-acquired infection (possible)

Procedures

pneumonectomybronchoscopychest X-rayCT scanlung function testingintubationmechanical ventilation

Contributing factors

  • malnutrition contributing to TB development and progression
  • severe exploitation and poor living/working conditions
  • relapse of TB despite initial drug treatment
  • disease in both lungs at time of surgery
  • extensive destruction of right upper and lower lobes requiring pneumonectomy
  • post-operative complications in remaining left lung
  • delayed diagnosis - disease was advanced before medical presentation
  • discharge from screening programme without adequate assessment of symptoms or circumstances

Coroner's recommendations

  1. Pre-discharge interviews with patients being screened for TB should be undertaken face-to-face and include a physical check for signs of possible active TB or risk factors for activation of TB
  2. When considering discharge, physicians reviewing patients' most recent chest x-rays should do so with the benefit of the radiologist's report
  3. NSW Minister for Health and Minister for Immigration should confer to find optimal policies for ensuring that health and welfare of temporary visa holders subject to TB health undertakings (or similar public health undertakings) are protected, and public health is safeguarded
Full text
Official source Archived copy

Related cases from NSW

NSWhospital2026-02-26

Inquest into the death of Jeremy Webb

16y · Male·Anaphylaxis due to mammalian meat allergy after tick bite, causing an acute exac…

Jeremy Webb, 16, died from anaphylaxis due to mammalian meat allergy (tick-induced) which triggered status asthmaticus. He had experienced red meat reactions since age 10 and a severe respiratory event in April 2021 that…

emergency medicineallergy and immunologydiagnosticcommunicationadrenaline
NSWhospital2026-01-13

Inquest into the death of Paul Harris

43y · Male·Bilateral pulmonary thrombo-emboli; contributory factors included obesity, coron…

Paul Harris, a 43-year-old Aboriginal man, died from bilateral pulmonary emboli while hospitalized at Hay District Hospital. He presented in September 2019 with pneumonia and Q fever (occupational exposure from kangaroo …

general practiceemergency medicinediagnosticcommunicationceftriaxone
NSWhome2025-12-17

Inquest into the death of MQ

55y · Female·acute necrotising bronchopneumonia

MQ, 55, died of acute necrotising bronchopneumonia on 2-3 March 2023. She had developed community-acquired pneumonia from 21 February 2023, presenting initially with referred shoulder pain (later recognised as diaphragma…

general practiceemergency medicinediagnosticdelay

Source and disclaimer

This page reproduces or summarises information from publicly available findings published by Australian coroners' courts. Coronial is an independent educational resource and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of any coronial court or government body.

Content may be incomplete, reformatted, or summarised. Some material may have been redacted or restricted by court order or privacy requirements. Always refer to the original court publication for the authoritative record.

Copyright in original materials remains with the relevant government jurisdiction. AI-generated summaries and tagging are for educational purposes only, may contain inaccuracies, and must not be treated as legal documents. We welcome feedback for correction — report an inaccuracy here.