Inquest into the Deaths of Chantelle Jane McDOUGALL, Leela McDOUGALL, Antonio Konstantin POPIC and Gary FELTON

Female·not established beyond reasonable doubt

This finding concerns four missing persons from Nannup, Western Australia (Chantelle McDougall, Leela McDougall, Tony Popic, and Simon/Gary Felton) who disappeared on or around 16 July 2007. While the coroner found reasonable grounds to suspect they are dead—particularly given their complete lack of contact with families, lack of bank activity, absence from all official records, and evidence of Simon's depression and spiritual beliefs about 'ascension' through death—the coroner could not establish any death beyond reasonable doubt. The evidence presents two competing hypotheses: either the group died by suicide (supported by Simon's despondency, emails discussing family suicide plans, spiritual beliefs about transcendence, and access to sedative medications), or they orchestrated disappearances and are living in seclusion (supported by their deceptive practices, preparation activities, Simon's history of assuming false identities, reported sightings, and the lack of definitive forensic evidence). The finding highlights significant investigative failures, including failure to conduct early forensic examination of the property, insufficient follow-up on reported sightings and potential burial sites, and lack of thorough searches in specific locations.