Coronial
SAhome

Coroner's Finding: Baby Safe Sleeping Practices

Deceased

Zara Marie Schupelius, Callum Daryl Walter Smith, Jake Vincent Hackett, Rachel Von Smith, Paige Louise Clark

Date of death

2005-2006

Finding date

2008-06-25

Cause of death

Zara Schupelius: suffocation; Callum Smith: undetermined; Jake Hackett: suffocation; Rachel Von Smith: suffocation; Paige Clark: undetermined

AI-generated summary

Concurrent inquests into five sudden unexpected deaths in infancy (SUDI), three attributed to suffocation and two undetermined but with suffocation as a significant possibility. All deaths occurred in infants aged 2-7 months placed in sleeping environments with identified hazards: soft mattresses creating dangerous depressions, V/U-shaped pillows, inflatable plastic beds, co-sleeping arrangements, and heavy bedding. Key clinical lessons: safe sleeping environments are critical for preventing infant asphyxiation; firm mattresses, back sleeping position, minimal bedding, and individual cots are essential; unsafe sleeping practices can be readily identified and eliminated; healthcare professionals including midwives should consistently advocate evidence-based safe sleeping guidance; vulnerable socio-economic families need targeted support and education to provide safe sleeping environments.

AI-generated summary and tagging — may contain inaccuracies; refer to original finding for legal purposes. Report an inaccuracy.

Specialties

forensic medicinepaediatricsgeneral practice

Error types

systemcommunication

Clinical conditions

asphyxia by suffocationaccidental asphyxiationpositional asphyxiahypoxic-ischaemic injury

Contributing factors

  • soft mattress with dangerous trough/depression
  • prone or face-down sleeping position
  • V-shaped or U-shaped pillows unsuitable for infants
  • inflatable plastic bed with troughs between side panels and base
  • heavy bedding, quilts and blankets
  • co-sleeping with adults or other children
  • lack of firm mattress
  • overheating from electric blankets and heavy bed clothing
  • gaps between mattress and cot side enabling wedging
  • inadequate education on safe sleeping practices
  • lack of awareness of product safety hazards

Coroner's recommendations

  1. Minister for Families and Communities and Minister for Health to act upon and fund recommendations of Child Death and Serious Injury Review Committee including: public health campaign for safe sleeping directed at young parents; product safety analysis for any product implicated in infant death; provision of safe sleeping environments for all infants; state-wide programs to build knowledge and confidence of parents and carers; state-wide support programs for disadvantaged families including provision of appropriate cots and ongoing support
  2. Develop single set of consistent guidelines defining appropriate strategies by parents, carers and health professionals for reduction of SUDI risk factors
  3. Develop strategies for community-wide education on safe and unsafe infant sleeping practices to enable identification and elimination of unsafe practices
  4. Direct educational programs to nursing profession, carers and other health professionals on safe sleeping practices to ensure consistent and accurate information to parents
  5. Ensure nursing profession, carers and health professionals direct consistent safe sleeping messages in accordance with SIDS and Kids, Kidsafe and Women's and Children's Hospital recommendations, specifically: infants should sleep on backs from birth; parents should only deviate from safe practices on medical advice
  6. Develop strategies to identify new parents at risk of unsafe infant sleeping prior to hospital discharge; provide appropriate information to at-risk parents
  7. Undertake formal product safety analysis of inflatable plastic beds to determine specific hazards for infants under 3 years and ensure warnings address suffocation as well as choking hazards
Full text
Official source Archived copy

Related cases from SA

SAcommunity2026-03-26

Coroner's Finding: Shepley, Adam Troy

30y · Male·Unascertained; likely cardiac arrhythmia

Adam Troy Shepley, aged 30, died in police custody following restraint after climbing onto roofs while displaying drug-affected and paranoid behaviour. Post-mortem examination revealed an unascertained cause, likely a ca…

emergency medicineparamedicinediagnosticcommunicationmethamphetamine
SA2025-05-20

Coroner's Finding: Pham, Duy Ngoc

35y · Male·multiple organ failure due to out-of-hospital circulatory arrest due to perforat…

35-year-old male died from multiple organ failure following out-of-hospital cardiac arrest caused by perforated duodenum. He was in police custody for drug-related charges and diagnosed with opioid withdrawal. Critical d…

emergency medicinegeneral practicedelaycommunicationmethamphetamine
SAhome2024-09-13

Coroner's Finding: Sulley, Matthew Wade

46y · Male·neck compression due to hanging

Matthew Wade Sulley, aged 46, died by hanging while on home detention under Department for Correctional Services supervision. He had a significant psychiatric history including previous suicide attempt by hanging (1997),…

forensic medicinepsychiatrycommunicationsystemmethamphetamine

Source and disclaimer

This page reproduces or summarises information from publicly available findings published by Australian coroners' courts. Coronial is an independent educational resource and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of any coronial court or government body.

Content may be incomplete, reformatted, or summarised. Some material may have been redacted or restricted by court order or privacy requirements. Always refer to the original court publication for the authoritative record.

Copyright in original materials remains with the relevant government jurisdiction. AI-generated summaries and tagging are for educational purposes only, may contain inaccuracies, and must not be treated as legal documents. We welcome feedback for correction — report an inaccuracy here.